- Home
- Scholarship
- The Real Cost of Silly Mistakes
The Real Cost of Silly Mistakes
2026 Driver Education Round 2
Benjamin Kaufman
Boca Raton, FL
During one practice session, I needed to move into the left lane on a busy four-lane road. I signaled and checked my mirror without looking over my shoulder. A car was in my blind spot, its driver honked, and I steered back into my lane. Nothing touched. My instructor asked what I was going to do about it, and I said I would be more careful. I had been saying that about careless errors in school for years, and it almost never worked there either.
Because I still had practice hours left, I could do something besides promise. I wrote the mistake down and labeled it a critical error, which to me meant any error that could kill someone. Then I made a rule that I wouldn't merge onto a highway until I had done every lane change on surface streets correctly, shoulder check included. That took about two more weeks. With only the minimum hours, I think I would have kept the habit and told myself I had fixed it.
Nothing bad happened when I skipped that shoulder check, and honestly that's what bothers me most about it. If the other driver hadn't honked, I wouldn't have known I did anything wrong, and I probably would have done it again the next day. NASA ran into the same thing with the space shuttle. Engineers kept finding damaged O-rings after flights, and since those shuttles still came home fine, the damage slowly stopped seeming like a big deal. A sociologist named Diane Vaughan later called this the normalization of deviance, and it's a pretty good description of how bad driving habits form. Someone texts at a red light, nothing happens, and the next time they keep texting as the light turns green. At school, if I mess up a problem on a worksheet, it comes back with a circle around it. Skipping a mirror check doesn't come back with anything, and the first time it does, it might be a crash.
That's why I think driver's ed matters as much as it does. For a few months, someone sits next to you whose whole job is to notice the stuff you'd get away with on your own. There's data behind this too. Researchers at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln went through the records of almost 152,000 teen drivers in that state over eight years. The ones who never took driver's ed were 16 percent more likely to crash and 75 percent more likely to get a ticket, and they were 24 percent more likely to end up in a crash where somebody got hurt or died. Nationally, NHTSA's early estimate puts traffic deaths in 2025 at 36,640, or roughly 100 people a day. New drivers face the most risk. The IIHS reports that per mile driven, drivers ages 16 to 19 have a fatal crash rate just over three times the rate for drivers 20 and older.
Fewer people would die if more of these mistakes were caught during training. Practice tests that students can retake help with the written side, since getting a question wrong there doesn't hurt anyone and tells the student what to go back and study. Behind the wheel, instructors and parents could keep track of which mistakes are dangerous and hold a student back from harder driving until those are fixed. Families can also set rules about phones before a teen ever drives alone, since it's easier to build that habit from the start. States have a role too. The IIHS reports that strong graduated licensing programs are linked to lower fatal crash rates for young drivers, and that limits on driving at night and with teen passengers have reduced fatal crashes.
I still keep my list. Skipping the shoulder check is on it, along with rolling through right turns on red and having my phone within reach. My phone goes in the glove box before I start the car. When friends ride with me, I tell them before we leave that my phone stays there, and I ask whoever is in the front seat to handle directions and music. If I catch myself doing one of these, I stay on slower roads and don't drive friends around until I've practiced enough to trust myself again. When friends of mine get their permits, I show them the list and tell them about the rule. I also speak up from the passenger seat when the driver skips a check, which my friends don't always appreciate.
I don't think a driver has to be perfect at everything. A missed question on a permit test or a turn that swings a little wide is not going to kill anyone. Some mistakes can, and for those I don't allow myself any. Driver's ed, and especially the extra practice, is where I learned to tell the two kinds apart. When I make one of the dangerous ones now, I go back and practice until it's gone.
Content Disclaimer:
Essays are contributed by users and represent their individual perspectives, not those of this website.
How to Merge Onto the Highway (For the First Time): A Manifesto for Change
Tekla Schreiner-Witte